Chilcot: a devastating critique of government in the UK
The report of the Inquiry conducted by Sir John Chilcot is a devastating condemnation of the Blair government’s decision to participate in the invasion of Iraq in March 2003. It provides a long list of failures, which demonstrates unbelievable incompetence, which has resulted in death, destruction and suffering on a huge scale. One of the key factors was the crucial role of the reports on intelligence.
The conclusion of Chilcot was that:
“The Government’s strategy reflected its confidence in the Joint Intelligence Committee’s Assessments. Those Assessments provided the benchmark against which Iraq’s conduct and denials, and the reports of the inspectors, were judged.
As late as 17 March, Mr Blair was being advised by the Chairman of the Joint Intelligence Committee that Iraq possessed chemical and biological weapons, the means to deliver them and the capacity to produce them. He was also told that the evidence pointed to Saddam Hussein’s view that the capability was militarily significant and to his determination – left to his own devices – to build it up further.
It is now clear that policy on Iraq was made on the basis of flawed intelligence and assessments. They were not challenged, and they should have been
Parallels with public health
Although public health might seem to be completely different from a decision to go to war, the similarities in terms of policy formulation are quite striking when considering the present policy on diabetes.
As I will explain, huge numbers of people are suffering from diabetes, especially Type 2 (T2D) and current policies are one of the major reasons why their condition is deteriorating. As a consequence, they are forced to endure a poor quality of life and many of them die prematurely.
The incidence of diabetes has doubled in the past 15 years. It costs the NHS about £10 Billion and all the indications are that it will continue to increase for the foreseeable future. It must be obvious that the existing policies are failing badly. Nevertheless the politicians continue to persist with precisely the same strategy.
Diabetes is diagnosed by raised levels of glucose in the blood. Type 1 (T1D) is the result of damage to the pancreas so that it has lost the ability to produce insulin. It is the insulin which keeps the blood glucose under control. For those who suffer from T1D, insulin therapy is essential for survival. By contrast, T2D develops gradually and almost certainly is caused by persistent high consumption of sugar and foods which contain starch, which is broken down in the gut to release glucose. We now have good evidence that the solution to T2D is to tackle the basic cause by reducing the consumption of sugar and other sources of carbohydrates in the diet.
In the UK, the main emphasis for the treatment of T2D is on the use of drugs to control the blood glucose. With respect to lifestyle, the advice is to take more exercise, which is makes good sense. Patients are also advised to lose weight, even though the usual approach of calorie reduction has a very poor record of success. The conventional advice on diet is to reduce the fat and replace it with carbohydrates.
Policy is just not working
So the fundamental problem is that the key element of the official Diabetes Prevention Programme is one of the primary causes of the current epidemic. Those who follow the advice to increase the consumption of carbohydrates inevitably get worse, while those who do the exact opposite invariably show some improvement. Furthermore there are numerous examples of individuals who have been able to stop taking drugs altogether by adopting this approach.
The big question is:
“Why does government and the health/medical establishment persist with a fundamentally flawed policy?”
It is quite clear that there is a complete failure/inability to conduct an objective analysis of the issues. There must be another agenda, which is a powerful driving force. All the indications are that any information which does not fit in with the current predominant concepts are simply discounted. This is an exact parallel with the attitude to “weapons of mass destruction” (WMD). A recent BBC radio programme has revealed that there were several intelligence reports, which concluded that Sadam Hussein did not have WMD. One of these cost the Americans $200,000. All of these were rejected on the grounds that “they would say that!”
Failure to challenge the advice from the “experts”
The standard advice is accepted without being challenged. When I wrote to my MP with evidence showing the benefits of a low carb diet for those with T2D, my letter was forwarded to the junior Minister in the Department of Health (DoH), Jane Ellison. This is the reply:
With regard to low carbohydrate diets, the Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition (SACN) has published its report “Carbohydrates and Health” in July. In that report, SACN considered evidence from a wide range of prospective studies and randomized controlled trials that investigated the relation between consumption of carbohydrates and various health outcomes. The evidence considered by SACN for this report does not support the suggestion that consuming a diet low in carbohydrates and high in fats would reduce the risk of type 2 diabetes, but found that greater consumption of sugar sweetened beverages is associated with increased risk.”
This SACN report is very poor because it ignores much relevant research which provides sound justification for the use of low carb as a means of controlling T2D. The reply from the Minister made no attempt to reply to the specific points which I made.
A lost opportunity
Although I am writing this when a new Prime Minister has just taken office, Jeremy Hunt will be continuing as the Minister responsible for health. This suggests it is unlikely there will be any change for the better. Yet the reality is that if the present trends continue, the costs will not be sustainable. Eventually, new policies will have to be devised and it would make very good sense for this to happen sooner rather than later.
Conclusion
In the meantime, I have no doubt that pressure will be building up from the grassroots, as more and more individuals find out for themselves that T2D can be overcome by relatively easy changes that can be made to the diet.
Verner,
Yet again vested interests. Weathervane politicians will blame any poor decisions they are forced to admit to on poor advice (mistakes were made but not by me) and they always have an eye on potential income sources once their government days are over so will be careful not to rock the boat. I think most people are aware of the sort of person Jeremy Hunt is and will not be holding their breath waiting for help from him.
The faulty diet advice for diabetics is a direct result of the American led dietary changes that demonised fat and saturated fat in particular. A good diet would be high in natural fats, low in carbohydrate plus appropriate protein but if fat is deemed bad and too much protein harmful then the gap can only be filled by carbohydrate. So as long as your mind is closed to the truth then there is little option other than to promote carbohydrate (the fact that various diabetic associations state that medication may (“will” would be more appropriate) need to be increased should be a wakeup call. This of course plays right into the hands of the junk food industry which is only too happy to provide lots of cheap carbohydrate based products of which many are addictive. Plus, yet again, the pharmaceutical companies profit from increased drug sales. We live in a corrupt world where the truth is not welcomed if it affects profits.
You are no doubt aware of the current issues Tim Noakes is facing and then there is the case of Jennifer Elliott (this is one of many links to the case http://www.zoeharcombe.com/2015/10/jennifer-elliott-vs-dietitians-association-of-australia/ ) and there are others. Bottom line is that doing the right thing will get you into trouble.
The Tim Noakes “trial” comes to a head next month. It has just been announced that Zoe Harcombe and Nina Teicholz are to be the expert witnesses.V
Verner,
That is excellent news. We’ll see who the establishment wheel out to support their position knowing that it is indefensible and so easily proven wrong. Tim Noakes won’t back down and the establishment will be looking for a way to exit this farce with some pride intact and without admitting defeat. I think they’ll find they have too many plates spinning on sticks.
Will be following the proceedings carefully. Hopefully Marika @MarikaSboros will provide ball-by-ball commentary with her Tweets. V
God bless Dr sebi for helping me cure my diabetes type 2. Brethren, i have suffered diabetes for a long period of time, i have tried so many remedy and some insulin, but known seems to work. But i had contact with a herbal doctor who i saw so many people testifying on how they were all cured of their various disease and viruses by this doctor. So i explained my entire problem to him, and he promised to cure me. So i gave him all benefit of doubt, and behold he prepared the herbal mixture, and send it to me in my country. Today, i am proud to say i am diabetes free, and my sugar level has been restored to normal. So in case you are out there suffering from diabetes and other diseases or virus, i want to tell you to quickly contact: dr.sebitradomedical@gmail.com or whatapp +2348148339190
It’s been calculated that if evary GP followed Dr David Unwin’s lead the NHS would save nearly half a billion per year.
Of course another way of looking at it is that the drug companies would LOSE half a billion per year. Now you know why doctors have not been told and will not be told how to achieve this.
If everyone stopped eating “low fat” manufactured foodlike substances huge profits would no longer be made (don’t forget obese people eat more food by definition and are therefore more profitable).
If everyone lived to be 95 (like my mother) or 108 (like one of my neighbours) imagine the effect on the profits of the pension industry, and more so the NHS. Premature death leaves them more money to be spent on the gainful employment of more managers.
I never taught Dr EDWIN who could ever get my HIV-AIDS cured with his herbal product.despite all these happening to me.I always spend a lot to buy a HIV drugs from hospital and taking some several medications but no relieve until one day i was just browsing on the internet when i came across a great post of ! Williams Fran-ca who truly said that she was been diagnose with HIV and was healed that very week through the help of these great powerful healing spell doctor. sometime i really wonder why people called him Dr EDWIN,i never knew it was all because of the great and perfect work that he has been doing that is causing all this. so i quickly contacted him and he ask me some few questions and he said a thing i will never forget that anyone who contacted him is always getting his or her healing in just 6 hours after doing all he ask you so i was amazed all the time i heard that from him ,so i did all things only to see that at the very day which he said i will be healed all the strength that has left me before rush back and i became very strong and healthy this disease almost kills my life all because of me.so i rush to hospital for the final test. So the doctor said i am HIV negative i am very amazed and happy about the healing Dr EDWIN gave to me from the ancient part of Africa ,with a strong herbal concoction. if you are infected with any disease like HIV, AIDS, CANCER,HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS, or any other disease you can also be happy like me by contacting….. Name: Dr.EDWIN What apps Number: +2348023949859 Email: draziengbe@outlook.com I“m given you 100% grantee, soon as you have getting in touch with Dr.EDWIN your problems will be solved accurately. Thanks..
I’m so thankful to Dr bolala for his wonderful work done for me. i am Jane Scott from Washington Indiana, i have been diagnosed of herpes disease for a long time and it have affected my job and i almost lost my job because i was suppose to be physically and healthily fit for the job without any disease but i slept with a stranger that i barely know and i was affected, i searched out for all remedy that i could, but all was a disappointment, until i met with the great Dr bolala who i discussed with and he promised to help me, and not too long he prepared a powerful medicine for me and when i used it for 5weeks i was totally cured i am so happy to be cured from Dr bolala herbal medicine, you too can be cured just contact him now on this email:doctorbolala@gmail.com
or his mobile Number/ what app:+2348082281460
He also have a herbal cure for Following DISEASES,this is not scam is 100% Real
-COLD SORE
-ALS
-LOWER RESPIRATORY INFECTION
-LOW SPERM COUNT
-STAPHYLOCOCCUS AUREUS
-STROKE
-IMPOTENCE
-PILE
-HYPERTENSION
-LOW SPERM COUNT
-ASTHMA
-CANCER
-BARENESS/INFERTILITY
-FIBROID
-ASTHMA
-SICKLE CELL
-BARENESS/INFERTILITY
-DIARRHEA and so on…